I'm not saying the bishop was wrong, or he was a loser, or making any other assumption.....
However, I can honestly say that I never had a BYU Bishop that I liked. I don't think its just me because I've loved every bishop in every other ward I've ever been in including my family ward here in Provo. But for some reason it has always seemed to me that BYU bishops like to make up their own stupid standards and act like they are your parents. I had one of the famous Ludlow dudes for a bishop once and I couldn't stand the guy.
That being said, I still went to church (-: But, some of these BYU bishops have their own crazy ideas about worthiness and would even try to get you kicked out of byu for something as stupid as french kissing. Anyway, had to just get that off my chest!