harlinestillopen wrote:

Oh give Cook a break. Just because he didn't fallow the typical Cornell/Cobain/ Alice in Chains/ what ever road, doesn't mean the guy isn't a rocker. What is he supposed to do on Idol? go aroudn head banging while tearing up his guitar? He did the show to get noticed. He's been noticed. He'll make a CD that is him, not what Idol wants him to be (which is what we've seen in his minute and thirty seconds each week

The problem is that his fan base comes from "what idol wants him to be". If he wants to build off what he's done on idol and keep the fans he's made he's going to have to stick with the poppy rock he's been doing on idol. Nothing wrong with that per se, if it makes him rich good for him. But it still very un-rock and roll.

I picture Jack Black saying "there used to be a way to stick it to the man with music, but oh no, the man had to go and ruin that too with a little thing called American Idol!"

Metallicat wrote:

harlinestillopen wrote:

Oh give Cook a break. Just because he didn't fallow the typical Cornell/Cobain/ Alice in Chains/ what ever road, doesn't mean the guy isn't a rocker. What is he supposed to do on Idol? go aroudn head banging while tearing up his guitar? He did the show to get noticed. He's been noticed. He'll make a CD that is him, not what Idol wants him to be (which is what we've seen in his minute and thirty seconds each week

The problem is that his fan base comes from "what idol wants him to be". If he wants to build off what he's done on idol and keep the fans he's made he's going to have to stick with the poppy rock he's been doing on idol. Nothing wrong with that per se, if it makes him rich good for him. But it still very un-rock and roll.

I picture Jack Black saying "there used to be a way to stick it to the man with music, but oh no, the man had to go and ruin that too with a little thing called American Idol!"

Amen brother

Ladies & Gentlemen, Brothers & Sisters, Whatever....
We all know it's a slow time for BYU sports so I'm reviving the thread each week. What do those who care think will happen tonight? My prediction is that Jason, I look like a girl with my eyes and hair, Castro is GONE! That is if America gets it right. It is possible Syesha or Brooke could also take a hike but I don't think either merit that if you judge by last nights' performances.

BTW, was Paula on something last night?

Go Cougs!!!

I predict that, much like the entire history of the show, I will not watch a single second of it.....

oh come on ABYUFAN, there are to many haters.

For anyone that does watch it alot, check out dialidol.com
http://dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp

They call in on everyone's lines, and based on how often its busy, they predict who is going home.

Here is the order they are predicting tonight. Now there is a margin of error, so its not full proof.

Syesha is SAFE. She could be has high as 1, or as low as 2.

David Cook is SAFE. Could be as high as 1, or as low as 2.

David Archuleta is in danger of being voted off. He could be as high as 3 or as low as 5

Jason Castro is in danger of being voted off. He could be as high as 3 or as low as 5.

Brooke White is in danger of being voted off. She could be as high as 3 or as low as 5.

this site usually gets the bottom 2/3 right, but has been off on who leaves.

After last nights performances I suspected that Brooke would be going home.

DialIdol is an interesting site, but don't place too much faith in it, for one thing it has no way to determine text messages, also, Idol claims they have some method to weed out auto-dialers from the tabulated votes, so a line could be busy quite often with auto-dialers that are weeded out.

I believe it will be two women in the bottom this time, with Syesha being safe, but Jason Castro ultimately going home.