Hey, when I went to the Y, I dated a girl whose roommate was dating the backup QB (Royce Bybee, who backed up Marc Wilson). He would sometimes bring over friends who were on the team,so I have actually been in the same room as BYU players. For some strange reason, this did not significantly alter my lifes path...
For that matter, Devin Durrant on the BBall team dated a girl in my student ward, and used to attend sometimes. But, still no miraculous happenings.